you were thinking about it, weren't you?

As it seems my niche as a Muse Hunter is now doing untested marketing gimmicks for indie games, to this end I was struck by an idea that I have decided to follow to its logical end. In a word, it's called "commission fanart and have them do so on stream to measure boost in wishlist counts". In my investigation, I find that there is no data on how well it "works", because no peers in industry have tried to do this before (and those I proposed it to were skeptical enough to not want to try). So I figured, I'm gonna do this on my own and get some nice fanart produced that can make a dev's day in the process.

We know for a fact that Game streamers increase wishlists, and so even the smallest ones are valued if they pick up a game demo and play it. We ask the question of whether other classes of streamers are undervalued in promoting indie games since everyone is focused on getting a variety game streamer and throwing others back in the ocean.

Stay Tuned

This post presents methodology and initial qualitative results. Stay Tuned for a follow-up where I analyze the raw numbers of the results!

Current State of the Art is Expensive and Ineffective

The current most-used strategy to market an up-and-coming indie game is contact Game streamers, give them keys, and pray that one with a million subs or more picks it up and plays it. Even if that does not happen, a sub-500 follower streamer will exert a nonzero impact on one's wishlist (WL) count. So every streamer counts.

Still though, the #1 thing guaranteed to kill the effectiveness of any streamer, big or small, is a sponsored stream. Simply paying a streamer to play your game is received VERY unfavorably, and for good reason. According to a mentor:

When a streamer (let's make them popular for argument's sake) normally streams, they get bigger views, but when they streamed with a bigass SPONSORED tag in the title, the viewership is like 5% of the regular. And this makes sense to me, after experiencing and learning about this β€” people know that this is not authentic and that the streamer might not have even picked the game up if not for the paid gig, so they opt not to watch.

Not to mention expensive. The least price the smallest streamers are willing to do it for is, from word of mouth, upwards of $1000. Budget indies do not have. This means this avenue of marketing is exclusively the domain of AAA titles with whole marketing departments. All for a vastly diminished impact on your WLC that that streamer would have otherwise given you.

But there is a type of streamer for whom "pay them to do something on stream" is not only seen as valid, it is their career. Commission Artists!

Hypothesis: The "Worth It" Threshold

To evaluate whether this alternative class of Twitch streamer that also operates as a Tertiary Vessel is undervalued, we must establish a benchmark for efficiency.

We define the marketing tactic of the "reverse commission" as "worth it" if an Art streamer commissioned for fan art (and willing to play the game on stream) generates at least 50% of the wishlist increase of an organic, unsponsored stream by a comparable reach Game streamer. Given that commission pricing is orders of magnitude lower than the $1,000+ baseline for sponsored game streams, pricing variance at this scale is negligible.

Bullshit Alert

There is no singular function that correlates social media stats to WL increase, not even approximately. Unless we have aggregate data from multiple streamers and multiple games, we cannot begin to define what a "comparable reach" streamer is objectively. Being "worth it" is going to have to be a purely qualitative analysis for the moment.

Experiment

Method

First, we get the corresponding developers' consent. The three games among my Charges Beholden that agreed to participate: Dead Horizon, Telegeddon, and the Compromise-verse.

Then, we recruit illustrators primarily on VGen with the following custom instructions, and see who bites:

Example Instructions, and Why You Provide Them

  1. 1.

    Play GAMENAME on stream to understand the assignment. (Self-explanatory.)

  2. 2.

    Illustrate the main character in whatever moment Spoke to you the most; also ON STREAM. (If not required in your instructions, it is up to them whether or not to illustrate on stream at all.)

  3. 3.

    Save timelapse but sped-up to less than a minute, formatted to vertical video. (Vertical short-form video is currently the most effective for marketing of any kind.)

  4. 4.

    Add generic music to the timelapse and (optionally) talk about what you liked about the game.

  5. 5.

    Post still illustration on all social medias, tagging the developer, the game name, and linking to the game. (Social media has one shot. You want to make sure their tags are right.)

  6. 6.

    Post timelapse on all platforms you have that use short video: TikTok, YT Shorts, and Instagram.

  7. 7.

    Note down the number of followers you have on each platform at time of posting. (For personal data collection.)

Approaching Commissioners with Bonus Work

Now, the artists you approach are not stupid. They can easily pick up on the fact that a gameplay stream, timelapse preparation, and social media prep constitutes "advertising" and β€” importantly for them β€” extra work. So DO NOT present the offer to them as a "standard" illustration. If you do, they can easily feel insulted for being "used" for free advertisement. Some may feel this is obvious advice but no... no it is not. I lost at least one person due to this.

As for Specifically, initiate the request as a CUSTOM inquiry. State that you want a standard illustration plus all the promotional stuff, and offer an initial budget for that.

Data Gathering

We just ask the developer for the Graph of Wishlists and itch downloads as a function of time for T+3 days after each social media activity.

🚨 GOODHART'S LAW ALERT 🚨

Measuring wishlists over 3 days is a number I pulled out of my butt as the expected number of days for the social media presence to exhaust its impact. There is always the possibility, however slim, that the social media post can have an unexpected impact after 3 days. In addition, the success or failure of this study WILL in turn affect the behavior of art streamers, who may choose to price their services differently and/or be more attuned to commission requests serving as indie game marketing. The more developers use this strategy, the more attuned artists become. See previous section for an example of how this behavior already manifests.

While attempting to gather streamers, I initially searched for those who streamed BOTH indie games and art on a regular basis. Turns out the intersection is so small I got very few results trawling social media, and the ones I did find declined to participate.

So what I did was just commission REGULAR Art-class streamers that were at least willing to stream playing an indie game outside their usual fare.

One thing I need to watch out for is how the usual audience reacts when pure art streamers play a game that is outside their usual lane. Are they as sensitive to a sponsored play of an indie game as the audience of Game-class streamers are?
This also affects the experiment, being forced to change my methodology. If indie devs rely on this rare intersection, this strategy is dead on arrival. VGen as a platform is also resistant to searching and sorting of any kind, making looking for streamers specifically a difficult or manual task.

🌟Stellar🌟 Preliminary Qualitative Results and Further Questions

The first commissioner I had was doing a piece for Dead Horizon. While the gameplay phase was unremarkable from a "stream-based entertainment perspective", several really good things happened in the illustration phase that make me want to analyze how "common" the behavior exhibited was.
Since she had fewer than 500 subs at time of illustration, her regular viewers were ones she knew personally over multiple interatctions.

  • One of them happened to be a game-class streamer for whom she spontaneously word-of-mouthed Dead Horizon's exciting story and climax. This gave me another streamer to network organically with.

  • Another Art-class streamer she allowed me to talk about my study (making an exception to her usual rules on self-promotion) since participating in the study was what she herself was doing right then. This gave me another prospective illustrator to commission.

  • The streamer was more relaxed during illustration, making all this behavior easier to happen organically.

This gives me a few questions for further study:

  1. 1.

    How often do Art-class and Game-class streamers befriend each other across the divide, and is this connection greater than within their own group, who are direct competitors?

  2. 2.

    Since the organic talk about the game happened during illustration, I hypothesize that drawing is a restful activity that allows a streamer to reflect on the game's story after the fact. Is this "restful" state common among all fanart commissions, as they are describing the scene they happen to be painting?

  3. 3.

    Does this behavior only exist at small subscriber counts? How does the behavior change as the number of subscribers increases? We MUST sample illustrators at different sub counts.

But they were weak

Unfortunately, Bumomo's posts generated exactly 2 wishlists, one of which was probably her. This is weak, but at the same time she is a sub-500. I have faith that larger sub counts will yield less weak impact. I want AT LEAST 3 data points for each game, so I can look at it more objectively and not be disheartened at a single "failure".

That's all for now. Stay Tuned for a follow-up post where I crunch raw numbers and answer the question of whether YOU should use commissioners the same way!

Stay Tuned

This study is still ongoing. If YOU happen to be an Art Streamer taking commissions, please contact me! The more data points we acquire, the better.